Skip to content
Tropely
Theme

5 “Who Did This to You?” Romantasy Books (+ 2 Sequels)

It's hard to pretend you don't care once you realise someone has been hurt. If you read “who did this to you?” romantasy books for that sudden glimpse of feeling, try Powerless for forbidden attraction, Dire Bound if you also enjoy “touch her and die”, or A Dawn of Onyx for hurt/comfort.

Below are five series you can start from book one, followed by two sequels to keep for later. There's room for different tastes in spice and darkness, and we'll leave the discoveries themselves for you to reach in the books.

Choose a series to start

The appeal of “who did this to you?” is in someone noticing the hurt and showing how much it matters to them. You might also want the care that follows in hurt/comfort, or the protective threats of “touch her and die”. They can sit happily in the same book, though a threat alone doesn't give you that moment of discovery.

If you'd prefer less spice, look at Powerless and Queen of Roses. We rate their spice None and Light respectively, but both are Dark. The heat rating describes sexual explicitness; it won't tell you how gentle the rest of the story is. Queen of Roses, for instance, has sexual-violence warnings.

All five books below are first volumes.

BookSpiceDarkness
A Dawn of OnyxMediumBalanced
Powerless — Lauren RobertsNoneDark
Dire BoundHighDark
Queen of RosesLightDark
The Stars Are DyingMediumDark

Each title links to book details and content notes. You'll also find app-download links there if you'd like to save books in Tropely.

Five romantasy books to begin with

A Dawn of Onyx cover

A Dawn of Onyx — a healer who needs help herself

Arwen can heal other people's wounds. Getting herself out of captivity is rather more difficult. In Kate Golden's A Dawn of Onyx, she is imprisoned and made to heal the Onyx King's soldiers. Help may come from a fellow prisoner, although his talent for aggravating her makes trusting him an unappealing prospect. Needing someone's help and actually liking them are, inconveniently, two different things.

There's a slow-burn, enemies-to-lovers romance here, with both “who did this to you?” and hurt/comfort in our catalogue. We'd start here if you want care alongside the protective concern. Arwen spends her days tending soldiers while needing a way out herself, and relying on somebody else means putting more than her feelings at risk.

Don't expect the captive-healer setup to be gentle throughout. The content notes include physical abuse, torture and threats of sexual assault.

Powerless cover

Powerless — forbidden attraction with something to conceal

Paedyn Gray has no powers, which is a dangerous thing to lack in Ilya. Being ordinary makes her an outlaw, so she survives by passing herself off as a Psychic. A sharp eye has to do the work of magic. Then she finds herself in trials designed to show off the very abilities she doesn't possess.

Falling for a prince is hardly going to help her keep a low profile. Lauren Roberts combines “who did this to you?” with enemies to lovers in a forbidden romance where being discovered could cost Paedyn her life. The kingdom's rules put the pair at odds, so there's more at stake than a bruised ego. Paedyn has to keep her disguise convincing while falling for someone who could discover the truth.

Dire Bound cover

Dire Bound — when you want “touch her and die” too

Meryn has a kidnapped sister to reach and very few reasons to trust the people standing between her and that goal. Military training puts her among recruits who despise her background, with an instructor who punishes weakness. Even the direwolf she's bonded to refuses to communicate. It is an exceptionally unpromising place to need an ally.

Sable Sorensen pairs that hostility with both “who did this to you” and “touch her and die”. If you like your protective romances to include threats as well as concern, put this one on the list. The romance is a slow burn, while Meryn's need to reach her sister gives her an urgent reason to keep going through the training. There's plenty for her to want, and fight for, beyond falling in love.

The danger does come with harsher material. The authors' content warnings include graphic violence, self-harm and sexual content involving dubious consent. Read those before settling in: enjoying a protective love interest doesn't mean you'll want everything that comes with this particular book.

Queen of Roses cover

Queen of Roses — Morgan Pendragon in an Arthurian fae world

Briar Boleyn takes us to Camelot with Morgan Pendragon, whose fae heritage and dangerous mission involving a powerful weapon open the Blood of a Fae series. If a quest through an Arthurian world sounds more inviting than another training academy, try Queen of Roses. Keep the darker content in mind if you're choosing it for comfort: the notes include abuse and sexual violence, despite the lighter spice rating.

We've included it for “who did this to you?”, with “touch her and die”, forced proximity and enemies to lovers also in the mix. A dangerous task is quite enough to be getting on with, even before the difficulty of being thrown into company with someone you don't like. Here, that familiar romantic friction comes with fae magic and an Arthurian setting to explore.

The Stars Are Dying cover

The Stars Are Dying — scars with a missing history

Even Astraea doesn't know how she came by her scars. In the opening of Chloe C. Peñaranda's The Stars Are Dying, she can see the marks, but can't remember what caused them. She has a past to uncover as well as hurt to reckon with.

Her memories are fragmented, and someone else's control has left her with little freedom. Looking for answers brings her into a bargain with Nyte. He offers protection, but trusting him is another matter. Accepting help from somebody you don't trust is an uncomfortable prospect, especially when you have so few answers about your own life. Astraea's search gives you a mystery to follow alongside the romance, with her freedom and her past both at stake.

If Astraea's missing past draws you in, this is the first book in the Nytefall series. The content notes include abuse, self-harm and sexual violence, so check those if the prospect of care is what brought you here.

Two sequels to keep for later

Save these for when you're further into the story. Fury Bound follows Dire Bound, while The War of Two Queens is the fourth Blood and Ash novel.

SequelPositionBegin with
Fury BoundBook 2Dire Bound
The War of Two QueensBook 4From Blood and Ash
Fury Bound cover

Fury Bound — return to The Wolves of Ruin

There's more “who did this to you?” ahead for readers following Meryn: Sable Sorensen lists it for Fury Bound too. Read Dire Bound first and let its ending bring you to the sequel. Meryn's circumstances are best discovered in that order.

Before continuing, take a look at the separate content notes for Fury Bound. They include on-page violence, self-harm and discussion of sexual assault and child abuse.

The War of Two Queens cover

The War of Two Queens — a book-four recommendation

If you want to stay with characters through the aftermath of harm, keep Jennifer L. Armentrout's fourth Blood and Ash novel in mind. We include it for “who did this to you?”, hurt/comfort and trauma recovery. Torture and captivity feature in its content notes, so don't mistake the promise of care for an easy time getting there.

New to the series? Begin with From Blood and Ash. There's a companion novel to fit in if you're reading the two connected series together: Armentrout's combined reading order puts A Shadow in the Ember after The Crown of Gilded Bones and before The War of Two Queens. Check that order before jumping straight from book three to four.

Still choosing? Browse more fantasy books with this trope.